Cigar Aficionado’s Top 25 Cigars of 2025
Every year, Cigar Aficionado releases its definitive list of the finest premium cigars, highlighting the year’s most exceptional smokes for aficionados worldwide. The 2025 edition showcases a curated selection of cigars that have earned top ratings for their flavor, construction, and overall smoking experience.
We’ve compiled the 2025 Top 25 Cigars into an easy-to-read guide, so you can quickly compare the best-rated sticks and add these award-winning cigars to your collection. For those looking to sample multiple top-rated cigars, be sure to explore our Cigar Aficionado Top 25 Samplers, designed to bring the very best of 2025 directly to your humidor.
(Note: We’re actively sourcing the remaining cigars from the list that aren’t yet in stock. This post will be updated with links to each product as soon as they become available.)
#25 Aladino 85 Aniversario Reserva Toro (93 Rating)
The Aladino 85 Aniversario Reserva Toro earns the #25 ranking with a 93 rating, showcasing a smooth, medium‑bodied Honduran puro that celebrates the legacy of Julio Eiroa with rich, well‑balanced flavor and expert construction. Crafted entirely with Honduran tobacco—including rare Pinareño seed wrapper, binder, and filler—the 6″ × 52 Toro delivers inviting notes of almond paste, baking spices like cinnamon, and a long, cookie‑like finish that highlights the vintage‑inspired blend. Its affordability and refined taste profile make the Aladino 85 Aniversario Reserva Toro an exceptional value in premium cigars, appealing to aficionados seeking a flavorful, handcrafted smoke with historical roots in Honduran tobacco tradition. SHOP ALADINO CIGARS
#24 La Aurora Family Creed Series Fuerte Sol Robusto (93 Rating)
The La Aurora Family Creed Series Fuerte Sol Robusto earns the #24 ranking with a 93 rating, thanks to its expertly blended medium‑full profile that combines Dominican Republic, Nicaraguan, and Pennsylvania filler with a Nicaraguan binder and a rich Mexican San Andrés wrapper for a complex and satisfying smoke. This 5″ × 50 robusto delivers layered tasting notes of oak, toasted nuts, cedar, and leather that crescendo into a smooth caramel finish, making the La Aurora Family Creed Series Fuerte Sol Robusto a flavorful and balanced choice for aficionados who enjoy bold character and refined construction in a box‑pressed format.
#23 La Aroma de Cuba Robusto (93 Rating)
The La Aroma de Cuba Robusto earns the #23 ranking with a 93 rating, standing out as a rich, full‑bodied premium cigar crafted by My Father Cigars S.A. in Nicaragua and wrapped in a dark Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper that delivers bold flavor at an exceptional value. This 5¼″ × 54 robusto combines Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos to produce a complex smoke with opulent notes of roasted peanut, toasted chestnut, and intriguing hints of licorice and minerals, paired with an ample draw and even burn that make it a satisfying choice for aficionados who enjoy robust, nuanced taste without breaking the bank. SHOP LA AROMA de CUBA CIGARS
#22 Olmec Maduro Grande (94 Rating)
The Olmec Maduro Grande earns the #22 ranking with a 93 rating, showcasing a smooth yet flavorful medium Maduro cigar that delivers rich, satisfying taste from start to finish. This 6″ × 54 grande from Olmec Cigars features a dark Mexican San Andrés Maduro wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler, producing a luxurious blend of espresso, dark chocolate, and baked bread with hints of cocoa nibs and cedar that evolve beautifully through the smoke. With its balanced construction and approachable strength, the Olmec Maduro Grande is a standout choice for aficionados seeking a classic Maduro experience with depth, complexity, and broad appeal.
#21 C.L.E. Maduro 50x5 (94 Rating)
The C.L.E. Maduro 50x5 earns the #21 ranking with a 94 rating, standing out as a full‑bodied Honduran cigar finished with a rich Mexican San Andrés maduro wrapper that complements its bold flavor profile. This 5″ × 50 robusto from Tabacalera C.L.E. S.A. combines Colombian and Honduran long‑fillers with a Honduran binder to deliver a core of spicy red pepper, cinnamon, and ginger balanced by deeper notes of leather and hearty wood, making the C.L.E. Maduro 50x5 a powerful and flavorful choice for aficionados who enjoy robust, complex cigars with exceptional construction and depth. SHOP NOW
#20 OneOff Black Toro (94 Rating)
The OneOff Black Toro earns the #20 ranking with a 94 rating, standing out as a medium‑full Nicaraguan puro that blends mystery and flavor in every draw. Handcrafted at Aganorsa Leaf’s factory in Nicaragua, this 6″ × 52 toro features all‑Nicaraguan tobacco—including a rare varietal rarely grown in the country—that delivers a compelling mix of sweet‑and‑spicy marzipan, white pepper, leather, and hearty grain notes, followed by nuanced earthiness that evolves from the first light to the finish. Its cult heritage, intriguing blend secrecy, and balanced yet bold profile make the OneOff Black Toro a must‑try for aficionados seeking a distinctive premium cigar with depth and character in 2025.
#19 Sancho Panza Belicoso Cuban Cigar (94 Rating)
The Sancho Panza Belicoso earns the #19 ranking with a 94 rating, highlighting its classic Cuban puro construction and rich flavor profile that appeals to aficionados seeking bold, traditional tobacco character. This 5½″ × 52 belicoso from Habanos S.A. features an all‑Cuban wrapper, binder, and filler that delivers medium‑full strength and decadently layered notes of chocolate, honey‑roasted peanut, toffee, and dried fruits like cherry, raisin, and fig, creating a dessert‑like complexity from the first draw to the last. Its combination of Cuban heritage, nuanced taste profile, and approachable box‑pressed format make the Sancho Panza Belicoso a standout choice among premium Cuban cigars. (Cuban cigars are not sold in the US)
#18 Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Robusto (94 Rating)
The Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Robusto ranks #18 with a 94 rating, showcasing a beautifully balanced medium Maduro cigar that highlights the depth and complexity of Nicaraguan tobacco with a Mexican Maduro wrapper. This 5″ × 52 box-pressed robusto from Tabacalera Oliva S.A. delivers a core of dark chocolate, raisin, and caramel flavors underscored by a subtle mineral quality from the first puff to the last, making it a standout choice for smokers who appreciate rich, refined taste and consistent construction in a classic Maduro profile. SHOP NOW
#17 Viaje Fifteen Plus Two And A Half Anniversary Silver (95 Rating)
The Viaje Fifteen Plus Two and a Half Anniversary Silver earns the #17 ranking with a 95 rating, showcasing a standout medium-full Nicaraguan puro that celebrates Viaje’s unconventional 17½-year milestone with bold flavor and impeccable construction. Box-pressed at Aganorsa Leaf in Nicaragua, this 6″ × 54 toro combines an all-Nicaraguan wrapper, binder, and filler to deliver rich, festive tasting notes of nutty earth, gingerbread, caramel, and Christmas cake with hints of candied orange peel and nutmeg leading to a smooth buttercream finish, making the Viaje Fifteen Plus Two and a Half Anniversary Silver a memorable and flavorful smoke for aficionados seeking a distinctive limited edition cigar. SHOP VIAJE CIGARS
#16 Gellis Family Cigars Saunter (95 Rating)
The Gellis Family Cigars Saunter takes the #16 ranking with an impressive 95 rating, earning recognition for its refined balance, craftsmanship, and outstanding value. This 5¼″ x 48 robusto is produced at Tabacalera La Isla in the Dominican Republic and features an Ecuadorian Connecticut-seed wrapper over an Ecuadorian binder with a Dominican and Nicaraguan filler blend. The result is a smooth, medium-bodied cigar that delivers layered notes of toasted nuts, clean wood, and subtle natural sweetness, offering depth without overpowering strength. Created by Kyle Gellis under his family-named brand, the Saunter stands out as a highly approachable yet flavorful premium cigar that appeals to both experienced aficionados and everyday smokers alike.
#15 Davidoff Millennium Blend Series Piramides (95 Rating)
The Davidoff Millennium Blend Series Piramides shines as #15 with a 95 rating, showcasing a masterful medium-full profile built around a proprietary “151” hybrid Ecuadorian wrapper over rich Dominican binder and filler that took master blenders years and hundreds of trials to perfect. This 6⅛″ × 52 Piramides delivers a deeply layered smoking experience, with decadent notes of maple candy, coffee bean, and dark chocolate framed by hints of oak, mocha, and baking spice on the finish, making the Davidoff Millennium Blend Series Piramides a standout in the luxury Dominican cigar category for aficionados seeking complex flavor and refined construction. SHOP NOW
#14 Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Concerto Impromptu (95 Rating)
The Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Concerto Impromptu ranks #14 on the 2025 Top 25 Cigars of the Year list with an impressive 95 rating, highlighting its sophisticated Nicaraguan puro construction and exceptional flavor profile. Crafted by Tabacalera A.J. Fernandez in collaboration with Rafael Nodal, this 6″ × 52 double-tapered figurado features an all-Nicaraguan filler, binder, and hybrid Criollo ’98 wrapper that delivers a medium-full strength smoke with a peppery core accented by spicy notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and bright hints of orange peel before a lively finish, making the Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Concerto Impromptu a standout choice for aficionados seeking a complex and memorable premium cigar in 2025. SHOP AGING ROOM CIGARS
#13 La Flor Dominicana 30 Years Chisel (95 Rating)
The La Flor Dominicana 30 Years Chisel secures #13 Cigar of the Year spot with an impressive 95 rating. This commemorative 6½″ × 58 Chisel figurado from Tabacalera La Flor S.A. honors three decades of LFD excellence with a rich Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper over Dominican binder and filler, delivering a medium-bodied smoke layered with opulent notes of leather, coffee, coconut, and clove that linger on the long finish. Its unique shape, exceptional construction, and complex flavor profile make the La Flor Dominicana 30 Years Chisel a standout choice for aficionados and collectors in 2025’s luxury cigar landscape. SHOP LA FLOR DOMINICANA CIGARS
#12 Macanudo Emissary France Churchill (Rating 95)
The Macanudo Emissary France Churchill earns Cigar Aficionado’s #12 Cigar of the Year on the Top 25 Cigars of 2025 list with an outstanding 95 rating. Crafted by Honduras American Tabaco S.A., this 7″ × 48 Churchill features a unique international blend highlighted by rare French tobacco in the filler, complemented by Brazilian, Dominican, and U.S. leaves, an Ecuador Habano wrapper, and a Connecticut Broadleaf binder for a refined, medium-full profile. Reviewers praise how the bold flavors of leather and black pepper balance with sweeter notes of coffee bean and cocoa, creating a complex and memorable smoke that stands out in the Macanudo lineup and among 2025’s top premium cigars. SHOP MACANUDO CIGARS
#11 Liga Privada T52 Corona Viva (Rating 95)
Liga Privada T52 Corona Viva earns Cigar Aficionado’s #11 Cigar of the Year in the prestigious Top 25 Cigars of 2025 list. This medium-full smoke from La Gran Fábrica Drew Estate scores an impressive 95 rating, highlighting the expert craftsmanship behind its rare stalk-cut Connecticut Habano wrapper, Brazilian binder, and rich Honduran-Nicaraguan filler. The 6″ × 46 Corona Viva delivers layered flavors of earth, caramel, baking spices like cinnamon and clove, finishing with notes of malt and stewed white raisin—making the Liga Privada T52 Corona Viva a must-try for aficionados seeking top-tier complexity and balance in 2025. SHOP NOW
#10 Ferio Tego Timeless Supreme 650 (Rating 95)
The Ferio Tego Timeless Supreme 650 earns its spot at #5, showcasing an outstanding 95 rating. This Dominican puro is a medium-full-bodied masterpiece, meticulously crafted with premium Dominican filler and binder tobaccos under a flawless, dark, oily wrapper. The 6 ½” x 50 Robusto-sized Timeless Supreme delivers a rich and complex flavor profile, opening with notes of espresso, dark cocoa, and toasted nuts, followed by subtle hints of cedar, leather, and spice that evolve beautifully throughout the smoke. Smooth and well-balanced, it offers a long, satisfying smoking experience that highlights the precision and expertise of Ferio Tego. Perfect for collectors and seasoned aficionados alike, the Timeless Supreme 650 exemplifies luxury, complexity, and premium Dominican craftsmanship in every draw. SHOP NOW
#9 Fuente Fuente OpusX Angel's Share Reserva d'Chateau (Rating 96)
The Fuente Fuente OpusX Angel’s Share Reserva D’Chateau secures its place at #9, boasting an impressive 95 rating. This limited-production Dominican puro comes from the renowned Fuente family, offering aficionados a medium-full-bodied experience that highlights the legendary OpusX lineage. Measuring 7” x 48, the Angel’s Share features a Dominican binder and filler with a flawless OpusX wrapper, delivering bold, complex flavors. From the first draw, smokers encounter rich notes of dark chocolate, espresso, and spice, intertwined with subtle hints of cedar, caramel, and dried fruits, creating a smooth yet layered smoking experience. Highly collectible and meticulously crafted, the Angel’s Share Reserva D’Chateau is a must-have for enthusiasts seeking a premium, high-end Dominican cigar with remarkable depth and balance. SHOP NOW
#8 Diplomaticos Genios Exclusivo Phoenicia Cuban Cigar (Rating 95)
The Diplomáticos Genios Exclusivo Phoenicia earns its spot at #8 on Cigar Aficionado’s Top 25 Cigars of 2025 with a stellar 95 rating. This Cuban Regional Edition, crafted for Phoenicia Trading A.A. in Cyprus, offers a rare opportunity to experience a limited yet widely accessible Cuban cigar. Measuring 5 ½” x 52, it features all-Cuban filler, binder, and wrapper, delivering a medium-full-bodied profile. Smokers are greeted with vibrant flavors of caramel, peaches, and autumn apples, layered with earthy cigar box notes and subtle tea tannins, creating a smooth yet complex smoking experience. With only 4,000 numbered boxes produced, the Genios is a collectible gem, perfect for aficionados looking to explore exclusive Cuban cigars with rich flavor and refined craftsmanship. (Cuban cigars are not sold in the US)
#7 Nasser The Goat By A.J. Fernandez Toro (Rating 95)
The Nasser The Goat by A.J. Fernandez Toro earns a prestigious #7 spot with an impressive 95 rating. Originally created as an exclusive blend for Nasser’s Lounge in Haiti before being released to the U.S. market, this medium-full-bodied Toro (6"×52) showcases AJ Fernandez’s blending mastery with a rich mix of Nicaraguan filler and binder beneath a dark Mexican San Andrés wrapper for deep complexity and smooth balance. Reviewers praised its flavorful profile—evoking chocolate-covered almonds, vanilla, earth, and coffee—that builds to a memorable finish of raisin and coconut rum cake, making this standout cigar a must-try for aficionados seeking depth and nuance in every draw. SHOP NOW
#6 Rocky Patel Emerald Robusto (Rating 95)
The Rocky Patel Emerald Robusto proudly claims the #6 spot with an outstanding 95 rating. This medium-full-bodied, box-pressed cigar was crafted to be slightly lighter than traditional Rocky Patel offerings while still delivering rich, complex character—a blend rolled in Nicaragua with dual binders from Mexico and Nicaragua and a smooth Ecuadorian Habano wrapper. Reviewers highlighted its harmonious profile of ground coffee, leather, hickory, and a touch of black pepper, balanced by a long, satisfying finish that keeps enthusiasts coming back for more. Accessible yet refined, the Emerald Robusto is a standout choice for both seasoned aficionados and those looking to elevate their premium cigar experience. SHOP ROCKY PATEL CIGARS
#5 Trinidad Espíritu Series No. 3 Belicoso (Rating 95)
The Trinidad Espíritu Series No. 3 Belicoso earned a standout #5 ranking on Cigar Aficionado’s Top 25 Cigars of 2025, boasting a 95 rating and showcasing a masterful blend crafted by A.J. Fernandez for the Trinidad brand. This 6⅛" × 52 Belicoso, built with Nicaraguan filler and binder wrapped in a rich Mexican San Andrés leaf, delivers a medium-full-bodied smoking experience marked by harmony and depth. Cigar Aficionado reviewers highlighted its beautifully balanced profile—combining sweet toasted vanilla, nougat, brown sugar, and toffee with subtle herbal and cedary notes—making it a must-try for enthusiasts seeking complex flavor and refined craftsmanship in a premium cigar. SHOP NOW
#4 Cuesta-Rey Centro Fino Sungrown Pyramid No. 9 (Rating 95)
The Cuesta-Rey Centro Fino Sungrown Pyramid No. 9 earned an impressive #4 ranking, with a 95 rating highlighting its standout quality and flavor. Handmade in the Dominican Republic by Tabacalera A. Fuente y Cia., this 6¼" × 52 Pyramid features a rich Ecuadorian Centro Fino Sungrown wrapper over Dominican binder and filler, designed to showcase bold, nuanced flavors. Cigar Aficionado reviewers praised the way each puff unfolds rich, nutty layers accented by notes of honey, nougat, chocolate, and a buttery cashew finish, making it a beautifully balanced and complex smoke that appeals to aficionados seeking depth and refinement in a medium-full-bodied cigar.
#3 Tatuaje Black Petite Lancero (Rating 96)
The Tatuaje Black Petite Lancero earned a prestigious #3 ranking, achieving an exceptional 96 rating and marking one of the highest honors of the year. This slender 6" × 38 lancero, handcrafted in Nicaragua by My Father Cigars S.A., highlights the art of concentrated flavor in a medium-strength format that belies its petite size. Reviewers praised the cigar’s rich, nuanced profile, with striking notes of sweet campfire s’mores-like sweetness balanced by oak and tannic structure, showcasing how such a small cigar can deliver immense complexity and depth from first light to the finish. Its outstanding balance of smooth, flavorful smoke and refined construction cements the Black Petite Lancero as a must-try for aficionados seeking a standout premium smoke in 2025. SHOP NOW
#2 Cohiba Ambar Cuban Cigar (Rating 97)
The Cohiba Ambar stands tall as the #2 cigar, earning an outstanding 97 rating and reaffirming its status as one of the year’s most exceptional premium cigars. Handmade in Cuba’s legendary El Laguito factory by Habanos S.A., this 5¼" × 53 Robusto Extra (Placeres vitola) features all-Cuban filler, binder, and wrapper tobaccos sourced from the famed Vuelta Abajo region, with some of the filler undergoing Cohiba’s signature extra barrel fermentation for unmatched smoothness and complexity. The Ambar delivers a beautifully balanced, medium-full-bodied smoking experience defined by a bold core of oak and caramel, surrounded by creamy, precise almond notes and finished with elegant fruit nuances, making it a must-try for aficionados seeking refined Cuban craftsmanship and depth of flavor. (Cuban cigars are not sold in the US)
#1 Cigar of the Year - Padrón 60th Anniversary Perfecto (Rating 97)
The Padrón 60th Anniversary Perfecto claimed the #1 spot on Cigar Aficionado’s Top 25 Cigars of 2025 with an outstanding 97 rating, making it the most celebrated cigar of the year. Crafted to commemorate Padrón’s 60th anniversary, this Nicaraguan perfecto (6½" × 56) represents only the second perfecto in the brand’s history and highlights the company’s mastery of tobacco blending and construction. Cigar Aficionado reviewers praised its rich, layered profile where notes of malted milk, cocoa powder, and creamy coffee combine to evoke a German chocolate cake effect, balanced with lingering hints of orange peel and milk chocolate on a long, refined finish. With flawless draw and burn, this limited-production masterpiece exemplifies premium cigar craftsmanship and complexity, making it a must-try for collectors and aficionados alike. SHOP PADRON CIGARS
See the official Cigar Aficionado Top 25 List
Thanks for visiting our online cigar shop! At Cigar Place, our mission is to offer the best prices, discounts, and deals on cigars, humidifiers, lighters, cutters, gifts, and other cigar accessories. Browse one of the largest selections of premium cigar brands and samplers online.
Want Free Shipping Any Day of the Week at Cigar Place? We have many options for you! Buy a cigar sampler, and get free shipping on your entire order. Buy a five-pack of cigars (or pick any 5 single cigars) and get free shipping. The same goes for bundle purchases, new arrivals, and, of course, any item with a "Free Shipping" banner on the picture. Click here to see all the ways you can get free shipping every day. Free cigar shipping for USA deliveries only.
Loading...