Twenty Years of Cigar Aficionado's #1 Rated Cigars 2004 - 2024 List

Cigar Aficionado's #1 Rated Cigars Since the Ratings Started in 2004

Cigar Aficionado, a leading publication in the world of cigars, began its annual "Top 25 Cigars" ranking in 2004. This list is one of the most anticipated and influential in the cigar industry, providing enthusiasts and collectors with a guide to the best cigars of the year. The process of ranking these cigars is thorough and based on a detailed evaluation by the publication's team of experts.

The cigars in this annual ranking span a wide range of brands and origins, from Cuban classics to newer blends from Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic, and beyond. This list helps cigar enthusiasts identify standout cigars that have earned top marks across multiple categories.

How Cigar Aficionado Ranks Cigars

To determine the rankings, Cigar Aficionado relies on a blind tasting process conducted by a panel of experienced cigar testers. The cigars are smoked without knowledge of the brand or price to ensure an unbiased evaluation. Each cigar is assessed on a variety of factors, including:

1. Flavor – The complexity, richness, and balance of the flavors are a primary focus.
2. Construction – The quality of the cigar's roll, draw, and overall consistency are critical.
3. Burn – A smooth and even burn contributes significantly to a cigar’s score.
4. Aroma – The scent and its influence on the smoking experience are also considered.
5. Value – The price point is taken into account when judging the overall value of the cigar.

The cigars are scored on a 100-point scale, and those that score the highest become part of the Top 25. The #1 cigar of the year is selected from this group, based on its superior performance in all areas.

CA's Top #1 Cigars from 2004–2024

Discover the pinnacle of premium cigars with our curated selection of Cigar Aficionado #1 Rated Cigars of the Year. Each year, Cigar Aficionado highlights the finest cigars, rigorously evaluated for exceptional flavor, craftsmanship, and quality. These top-rated smokes represent the very best in the cigar world, offering enthusiasts an unparalleled smoking experience. Whether you’re seeking the perfect addition to your humidor or a gift for a fellow aficionado, these celebrated cigars are sure to impress. Explore the legacy of excellence and enjoy a taste of the world’s most distinguished blends.

2024 #1 Cigar of the Year - My Father The Judge Grand Robusto

My Father The Judge Grand Robusto, crowned Cigar Aficionado’s #1 Cigar of the Year for 2024, is a bold yet refined smoke that embodies the Garcia family’s mastery of cigar craftsmanship. This Nicaraguan puro features a dark Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper encasing select Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos cultivated on the Garcias’ renowned farms. Measuring 5 inches by 60 ring gauge, the Grand Robusto delivers a rich, full-bodied experience with complex flavors of cocoa, espresso, leather, and a subtle spice that lingers beautifully on the palate. Its impeccable construction ensures an even burn and effortless draw, making each puff a testament to the brand’s commitment to excellence.

Earning the top spot in Cigar Aficionado’s annual rankings is no small feat, but My Father The Judge Grand Robusto lives up to the accolade with its remarkable depth and balance. The cigar showcases the artistry of José “Pepín” García and his son Jaime, whose meticulous blending techniques have consistently set My Father cigars apart in the industry. Aged to perfection, this robust yet elegant smoke captivates aficionados with its smooth transitions between earthy, sweet, and spicy notes, offering a luxurious experience from start to finish. Whether enjoyed by longtime My Father enthusiasts or those new to the brand, The Judge Grand Robusto stands as a true testament to Nicaraguan cigar excellence. SHOP NOW

2023 #1 Cigar of the Year - Fuente Fuente OpusX Reserva d’Chateau

The Fuente Fuente OpusX Reserva d’Chateau, named the #1 Cigar of the Year in 2023 by Cigar Aficionado, is a testament to the artistry and innovation of the Fuente family. Known for its flawless construction and luxurious smoking experience, this cigar exemplifies the pinnacle of premium Dominican craftsmanship. At the heart of its appeal lies the OpusX’s signature Rosado wrapper, grown exclusively on the Fuente family's estate in the Dominican Republic. This proprietary tobacco, aged meticulously, delivers a complex and harmonious flavor profile featuring notes of cedar, leather, spice, and subtle sweetness. Measuring 7 inches with a 48-ring gauge, the Reserva d’Chateau provides a long and indulgent smoking session perfect for special occasions or moments of quiet reflection.

What sets this cigar apart is its history and exclusivity. The OpusX line revolutionized the cigar industry by proving that world-class wrapper tobacco could thrive in the Dominican Republic, challenging long-held assumptions about Cuban leaf superiority. The Reserva d’Chateau showcases the peak of that innovation, combining unparalleled quality with a mystique that has captivated aficionados worldwide. With limited production and intense demand, securing one of these gems can be a challenge, but for those fortunate enough to enjoy it, the experience is nothing short of extraordinary. This cigar is a celebration of tradition, ingenuity, and the enduring legacy of the Fuente family. Learn More

2022 #1 Cigar of the Year - H. Upmann No. 2 (Cuban Cigar)

The H. Upmann No. 2 stands as a shining example of Cuban cigar excellence. This torpedo-shaped masterpiece, handcrafted in Cuba, boasts impeccable construction and a classic flavor profile that captures the essence of the island’s legendary tobacco tradition. Featuring a smooth, oily wrapper and a perfectly tapered head, the H. Upmann No. 2 delivers a luxurious smoking experience from start to finish. Its flavor profile unfolds with layers of creamy cedar, almond, and coffee, accompanied by subtle notes of honey and spice. The cigar’s medium-bodied nature makes it approachable yet complex, appealing to both seasoned aficionados and those new to Cuban cigars.

As one of the most iconic Cuban brands, H. Upmann has a storied history dating back to 1844, and the No. 2 is among its most celebrated vitolas. Known for its consistency and balance, the cigar exemplifies the meticulous craftsmanship that defines Cuban cigars, from its flawless draw to its smooth, slow burn. The No. 2 has long been a favorite among enthusiasts, but its 2022 accolade elevated its status, sparking renewed demand worldwide. For connoisseurs, the H. Upmann No. 2 offers not just a smoking experience but a journey into the rich heritage of Cuban cigarmaking, making it a must-have for any humidor.

2021 #1 Cigar of the Year - Padron 1964 Torpedo

The Padron 1964 Torpedo was crowned the #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2021, solidifying its place among the legends of the cigar world. Crafted by the renowned Padron family, this cigar is a shining example of their commitment to excellence and tradition.

Handmade in Nicaragua, the Padron 1964 Torpedo is part of the iconic 1964 Anniversary Series, created to commemorate the brand's 30th anniversary. Its box-pressed design exudes elegance, while the rich Nicaraguan sun-grown wrapper houses a perfectly aged blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos. With notes of cocoa, espresso, and a subtle sweetness balanced by hints of spice, this full-bodied masterpiece delivers complexity and refinement in every puff.

Praised for its flawless construction and exceptional flavor, the Padron 1964 Torpedo is a must-try for cigar connoisseurs seeking the best of the best.

2020 #1 Cigar of the Year - E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel

The E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel earned the coveted title of #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2020, cementing its place as a modern classic in the cigar world. Crafted by Ernesto Perez-Carrillo Jr., a master blender renowned for his artistry, this cigar is a testament to his dedication to quality and innovation.

Produced in the Dominican Republic, the Pledge Prequel features a stunning Connecticut Habano wrapper that envelops a carefully curated blend of Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. This robust combination delivers a symphony of flavors, including notes of rich chocolate, black cherry, and cedar, balanced with a subtle spice and a touch of earthiness.

Boasting impeccable construction and a smooth, nuanced profile, the E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel is more than just a cigar; it’s an unforgettable experience. Perfect for seasoned aficionados and newcomers alike, this award-winning gem represents the pinnacle of cigar craftsmanship. SHOP NOW

2019 #1 Cigar of the Year - Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro

The Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro was awarded #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2019, marking a groundbreaking achievement for Rafael Nodal and the Aging Room brand. This Nicaraguan puro, produced in collaboration with legendary cigar maker AJ Fernandez, is a masterpiece that showcases the depth and complexity of premium Nicaraguan tobaccos.

Handcrafted in Nicaragua, the Maestro features a vibrant Nicaraguan wrapper, binder, and filler that come together in a harmonious blend. The result is a symphony of bold and balanced flavors, with notes of dark chocolate, roasted coffee, and hints of spice, all underscored by a creamy, long-lasting finish. Its box-pressed torpedo shape not only enhances its elegant appearance but also ensures a smooth, consistent draw.

Praised for its meticulous construction and sophisticated profile, the Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro stands as a testament to the artistry and passion behind premium cigar making. For aficionados seeking a richly rewarding smoking experience, this cigar is an absolute must-try. SHOP NOW

2018 #1 Cigar of the Year - E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic

The E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic earned the #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2018, solidifying Ernesto Perez-Carrillo Jr.’s reputation as one of the world’s premier cigar makers. This masterpiece is part of the Encore series, a continuation of the highly acclaimed Perez-Carrillo Family Series, showcasing the artistry and passion that define the E.P. Carrillo brand.

Crafted in the Dominican Republic, the Encore Majestic is a Nicaraguan puro, featuring meticulously aged tobaccos that deliver a harmonious and complex flavor profile. The cigar greets the palate with notes of rich earth, baking spices, and subtle sweetness, evolving into layers of creamy caramel, toasted nuts, and a hint of citrus zest. Its medium-to-full-bodied strength and impeccable balance make it a joy for seasoned enthusiasts and newcomers alike.

With its flawless construction, smooth draw, and unforgettable flavor, the E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic exemplifies what it means to be a world-class cigar, deserving of its place at the top of every aficionado’s humidor. SHOP NOW

2017 #1 Cigar of the Year - Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark

The Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark is one of the most celebrated smokes in modern cigar history. This distinctive cigar is part of the renowned Don Carlos line, crafted as a tribute to Carlos Fuente Sr., a legend in the cigar world. Its unique box-pressed Belicoso shape immediately catches the eye, blending tradition with innovation. Wrapped in a beautifully aged Cameroon leaf and filled with expertly blended Dominican tobaccos, the Eye of the Shark offers a smoking experience that is both complex and perfectly balanced. Its construction, a hallmark of the Fuente family, ensures a smooth draw, even burn, and an elegant, lingering finish.

The flavor profile of the Eye of the Shark is where it truly shines, delivering an intricate symphony of notes. Smokers are greeted with a rich medley of cedar, nuts, and sweet spices, followed by nuanced layers of leather, cocoa, and caramel as the cigar evolves. The interplay between sweetness and earthiness is seamless, making each puff a delight for the palate. Recognized for its bold yet refined character, this cigar exemplifies why Arturo Fuente remains a leader in the industry. Whether enjoyed by seasoned connoisseurs or those seeking a premium cigar experience, the Eye of the Shark stands as a timeless masterpiece worthy of its accolades.

2016 #1 Cigar of the Year - La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull Figurado

The La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull Figurado was crowned #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2016. Created by Litto Gomez, the Andalusian Bull is an homage to his Spanish heritage and the rich traditions of bullfighting, reflected in the cigar's unique shape and bold character.

Handcrafted in the Dominican Republic, this masterpiece features an Ecuadorian Corojo wrapper that envelops a blend of Dominican binder and filler tobaccos cultivated on the La Flor Dominicana farm. Its striking figurado shape—a blend of artistry and functionality—enhances the smoking experience with a dynamic progression of flavors. The Andalusian Bull delivers a full-bodied profile rich with notes of leather, black pepper, and earth, complemented by hints of spices, dark cocoa, and a touch of sweetness.

With its impeccable construction, distinctive shape, and robust yet balanced flavor, the La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull is a must-try for those seeking a cigar that truly stands out. It’s a bold, complex smoke worthy of its award-winning status and a staple for connoisseurs worldwide.

2015 #1 Cigar of the Year - My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed

The My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed earned the prestigious title of #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2015, a testament to the Garcia family’s mastery in the art of cigar making. Created in honor of José “Pepin” Garcia’s late father, this cigar is a tribute to tradition, quality, and passion.

Handcrafted in Nicaragua, the Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed features a rich Nicaraguan Oscuro wrapper, perfectly aged to deliver a dark and oily sheen. Inside, a blend of premium Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos creates a full-bodied profile with remarkable complexity. Smokers are treated to an array of flavors, including dark chocolate, leather, and black pepper, balanced by subtle notes of earth, cedar, and a hint of sweetness.

The box-pressed torpedo shape not only adds to its visual elegance but also enhances the draw and burn consistency, ensuring a superior smoking experience. The My Father Le Bijou 1922 is a must-have for aficionados who appreciate bold, rich flavors paired with impeccable craftsmanship.

2014 #1 Cigar of the Year - Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado

The Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado was named #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2014, solidifying its status as one of the finest cigars in the world. This luxurious cigar is a shining achievement for the Oliva family, showcasing their commitment to exceptional craftsmanship and premium tobacco.

Handcrafted in Nicaragua, the Melanio Figurado is a work of art, featuring a stunning Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper that encases a rich blend of aged Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. This elegant figurado shape not only adds visual appeal but also enhances the smoking experience with a slow, even burn and a smooth draw.

The flavor profile is complex and refined, offering notes of caramel, cedar, and dark chocolate, complemented by hints of coffee, black pepper, and a touch of sweetness. Medium to full-bodied, the Melanio Figurado is perfectly balanced, delivering a luxurious and satisfying smoke from start to finish.

The Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado is a true masterpiece, celebrated by connoisseurs worldwide and a must-have for any serious cigar enthusiast. SHOP NOW

2013 #1 Cigar of the Year - Montecristo No. 2 (Cuban Cigar)

The Montecristo No. 2, honored as the #1 Cigar of the Year in 2013 by Cigar Aficionado, is one of the most iconic and highly regarded Cuban cigars in history. This legendary torpedo, with its distinctive tapered head, represents the gold standard of craftsmanship and quality in Cuban cigarmaking. Known for its consistently flawless construction, the Montecristo No. 2 offers a smooth and satisfying draw that delivers a complex array of flavors. Smokers can expect a rich profile featuring earthy notes of cedar and leather, complemented by hints of cocoa, coffee, and a subtle spiciness that builds as the cigar progresses. Its medium-to-full-bodied strength makes it a rewarding choice for aficionados seeking depth and character in their smoke.

First introduced in the 1930s, the Montecristo No. 2 has been a staple in humidors for decades, revered for its balance, consistency, and timeless appeal. Its recognition as the 2013 Cigar of the Year reaffirmed its status as a benchmark for quality and flavor, solidifying its place in the pantheon of great cigars. Beyond its impeccable construction and taste, the Montecristo No. 2 carries with it the prestige and tradition of Cuban tobacco heritage, making it a must-try for any serious smoker. Whether enjoyed during a moment of celebration or quiet contemplation, this cigar offers an unparalleled experience, embodying the artistry and legacy of one of Cuba’s most famous brands.

2012 #1 Cigar of the Year - Flor De Las Antillas Toro

The Flor de Las Antillas Toro was awarded #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2012, marking a milestone for the Garcia family and their renowned My Father Cigars brand. Translating to “Flower of the Antilles,” this cigar pays homage to Cuba, the birthplace of the Garcia family, and embodies their deep-rooted tradition and passion for cigar craftsmanship.

Handcrafted in Nicaragua, the Flor de Las Antillas Toro features a beautiful Nicaraguan sun-grown wrapper that envelops a blend of premium Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. The box-pressed construction not only enhances the cigar's aesthetic appeal but also contributes to an even burn and a smooth draw.

The flavor profile is medium to full-bodied, delivering a symphony of flavors with notes of nutmeg, cocoa, and pepper, balanced by a creamy sweetness and a hint of cedar. The cigar's impeccable balance and complexity make it a delight for both seasoned aficionados and those new to premium cigars.

Celebrated for its outstanding quality and unforgettable smoking experience, the Flor de Las Antillas Toro remains a must-try cigar for any enthusiast looking to enjoy a true masterpiece.

2011 #1 Cigar of the Year - Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill

The Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill earned the prestigious title of #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2011, catapulting Alec Bradley into the spotlight as one of the industry’s premier brands. Known for its bold character and refined craftsmanship, the Prensado Churchill is a testament to the artistry and passion behind every Alec Bradley creation.

Handcrafted in Honduras, this cigar features a stunning Honduran Corojo wrapper that envelops a blend of Nicaraguan and Honduran tobaccos. The Prensado Churchill is box-pressed, enhancing its elegant appearance while delivering a smooth, even draw and a consistent burn.

The flavor profile is rich and complex, offering notes of roasted coffee, dark chocolate, and leather, balanced with a touch of spice and a subtle sweetness. Full-bodied yet remarkably smooth, it provides a luxurious and satisfying smoking experience from start to finish.

The Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill is celebrated for its impeccable construction and depth of flavor, making it a must-try for any aficionado seeking a cigar that exemplifies quality and sophistication. SHOP NOW

2010 #1 Cigar of the Year - Cohiba Behike BHK 52 (Cuban Cigar)

The Cohiba Behike BHK 52 is a pinnacle of luxury in the world of premium cigars. Part of the ultra-exclusive Behike line, the BHK 52 stands out with its 4.7-inch length and 52-ring gauge, offering a refined and concentrated smoking experience. This cigar is crafted with a unique blend that includes medio tiempo leaves, a rare and flavorful tobacco harvested from the uppermost part of the plant. The result is a flavor profile that’s both complex and smooth, featuring creamy notes of cedar, leather, and earth, complemented by hints of cocoa, roasted nuts, and a touch of sweetness. Its medium-to-full body ensures a satisfying balance that delights seasoned aficionados.

Launched to commemorate Cohiba’s 40th anniversary, the Behike line represents the epitome of Cuban cigar craftsmanship. The BHK 52 is rolled by the most skilled torcedores at El Laguito factory in Havana, ensuring flawless construction and an effortless draw. The cigar’s elegant presentation, including its distinctive pigtail cap and ornate band, adds to its allure. As a limited-production item, the BHK 52 quickly became a coveted treasure among collectors and enthusiasts. Its recognition as the 2010 Cigar of the Year cemented its legacy as a masterpiece, offering an unparalleled smoking experience that celebrates the artistry and tradition of Cuban cigarmaking at its finest.

2009 #1 Cigar of the Year - Padron Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro

The Padron Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro earned the coveted title of #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2009, showcasing the Padron family's legacy of excellence in cigar craftsmanship. A true masterpiece, the Family Reserve series is known for its impeccable construction and rich, full-bodied flavor profiles, and the No. 45 Maduro is a standout example of these qualities.

Handcrafted in Nicaragua, this cigar features a beautiful Nicaraguan Maduro wrapper that envelops a blend of aged Nicaraguan tobaccos. The No. 45 Maduro’s box-pressed format not only enhances its presentation but also ensures a slow, even burn and a smooth, satisfying draw throughout.

The flavor profile is complex and rich, with bold notes of cocoa, coffee, and earth, complemented by a subtle sweetness and hints of spice. Full-bodied and deeply satisfying, the Padron Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro is an experience that captivates the senses, offering layers of flavor that evolve from start to finish.

A cigar that embodies the Padron family’s commitment to perfection, the Padron Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro is a must-have for serious cigar aficionados and remains a benchmark for premium cigars worldwide.

2008 #1 Cigar of the Year - Casa Magna Robusto Colorado

The Casa Magna Robusto Colorado earned the prestigious title of #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2008, a remarkable achievement that highlighted the excellence of the Casa Magna brand. This Nicaraguan puro, crafted by the renowned cigar makers Manuel Quesada and Nestor Plasencia, is celebrated for its balanced flavor profile, exceptional construction, and consistency.

Handmade in Nicaragua, the Casa Magna Robusto Colorado features a rich, oily Nicaraguan Colorado wrapper that encases a blend of aged Nicaraguan tobaccos. Its robust yet smooth profile is complemented by a slightly box-pressed shape that enhances the draw and burn, making it a truly pleasurable smoking experience.

The flavor profile is medium to full-bodied, offering an elegant fusion of spices, leather, and earthy undertones, with subtle hints of cocoa, coffee, and pepper. Its complexity and smoothness make it an approachable yet sophisticated cigar for both seasoned aficionados and newer cigar enthusiasts.

The Casa Magna Robusto Colorado remains a standout in the world of premium cigars, a must-try for anyone seeking a rich, flavorful smoke with impeccable construction and balance.

2007 #1 Cigar of the Year - Padron 1926 Serie No. 9

The Padron 1926 Serie No. 9 was awarded #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2007, cementing its status as one of the finest cigars in the world. Part of Padron’s 1926 Serie, which was created to celebrate the company’s 80th anniversary, this cigar exemplifies the Padron family’s commitment to excellence, using only the highest-quality Nicaraguan tobaccos and meticulous craftsmanship.

Handmade in Nicaragua, the 1926 Serie No. 9 features a stunning Nicaraguan Maduro wrapper that surrounds a blend of aged Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. Its perfect construction ensures an even burn and smooth, effortless draw, allowing the rich flavors to unfold with each puff.

The flavor profile is full-bodied and complex, offering a symphony of cocoa, coffee, and dark chocolate notes, balanced by subtle hints of earth, spice, and a natural sweetness. The cigar’s depth and richness make it a satisfying experience for seasoned aficionados, while its smooth finish ensures a pleasant, lingering aftertaste.

The Padron 1926 Serie No. 9 stands as a benchmark for luxury cigars, combining rich history, impeccable craftsmanship, and a luxurious smoking experience. It remains a must-have for any serious cigar enthusiast seeking the very best in premium cigars.

2006 #1 Cigar of the Year - Bolivar Royal Corona (Cuban Cigar)

The Bolívar Royal Corona is a robust and flavorful example of Cuban craftsmanship at its finest. This classic robusto measures 4.9 inches with a 50-ring gauge, offering a perfectly balanced smoking experience. Known for its bold character, the Royal Corona delivers a full-bodied profile that embodies the strength and richness associated with the Bolívar brand. Smokers can expect a complex symphony of flavors, including earthy notes of dark chocolate, leather, and espresso, intertwined with hints of cedar, spice, and a touch of sweetness. Its dense, creamy smoke and impeccable construction make it a consistent favorite among connoisseurs.

Bolívar, established in 1902, is celebrated for producing cigars with powerful yet refined profiles, and the Royal Corona is a standout in its portfolio. Its recognition as the 2006 Cigar of the Year cemented its reputation as a must-have for those who appreciate Cuban cigars. The Royal Corona’s perfect balance of strength and complexity makes it approachable for seasoned smokers while offering enough nuance to captivate even the most discerning palates. Whether enjoyed during a special occasion or as a daily indulgence, this cigar exemplifies the heritage and artistry of Cuba’s rich cigar tradition, earning its place among the finest smokes in the world.

2005 #1 Cigar of the Year - Fuente Fuente OpusX Double Corona

The Fuente Fuente OpusX Double Corona is a shining example of the Fuente family’s commitment to excellence and innovation. Measuring an impressive 7⅝ inches with a 49-ring gauge, this large-format cigar offers a long and luxurious smoking experience. Wrapped in the legendary Dominican-grown Rosado wrapper, the Double Corona showcases a blend of Dominican binder and filler tobaccos cultivated exclusively at the Fuente family’s Chateau de la Fuente estate. The result is a rich, full-bodied cigar with a complex flavor profile featuring notes of cedar, leather, spice, and a subtle sweetness, punctuated by hints of dried fruit and cocoa.

The OpusX line holds a special place in the history of premium cigars as the first to feature a Dominican puro with a wrapper grown outside of Cuba. It revolutionized the cigar industry when it was introduced, proving that Dominican-grown tobacco could produce cigars of unmatched quality and flavor. The Double Corona exemplifies this legacy, offering smokers a meticulously crafted cigar with an impeccable draw and a slow, even burn. Its 2005 recognition reaffirmed its status as one of the most sought-after cigars in the world, cementing the OpusX brand as a symbol of luxury, innovation, and the artistry of the Fuente family.

2004 #1 Cigar of the Year - Padrón Serie 1926 40th Anniversary

The Padrón Serie 1926 40th Anniversary, honored as the #1 Cigar of the Year in 2004 by Cigar Aficionado, holds a special place in cigar history as the first cigar to receive this prestigious title in the inaugural year of the magazine’s annual rankings. This box-pressed gem, crafted in Nicaragua, measures 6½ inches with a 54-ring gauge and showcases the exceptional quality and expertise that define the Padrón brand. Made entirely of aged Nicaraguan tobaccos, the cigar delivers a rich, full-bodied experience with impeccable construction and an effortless draw. Its flavor profile is a harmonious blend of cocoa, coffee, and earth, accented by notes of pepper, wood, and a touch of sweetness, creating a balanced and deeply satisfying smoke.

Released as a limited-edition cigar, the 40th Anniversary is part of the acclaimed Serie 1926 line, which was created to honor the birth year of company founder José Orlando Padrón. This cigar exemplifies the family’s unwavering commitment to quality, with each one undergoing meticulous craftsmanship and extensive aging to ensure consistency and complexity. The 40th Anniversary’s distinction as the first #1 Cigar of the Year in Cigar Aficionado’s rankings not only solidified Padrón’s place as one of the leading names in the premium cigar industry but also set the standard for excellence in the years to come. It offers enthusiasts a truly special smoking experience that celebrates tradition, excellence, and the artistry of Nicaraguan tobacco.

See Cigar Aficionado's Top 25 Archive

Behind the Scenes of Cigar Reviews & Ratings: How Cigars Are Scored and Ranked

Most cigar lovers are familiar with the Cigar Aficionado Top 25 list, but few truly understand what goes into a cigar review. Who smokes the cigars? How blind is the process? And what does a score of “92” really mean? In this article, we pull back the curtain on how cigars are evaluated, rated, and ultimately chosen as “Cigar of the Year.”

Why Cigar Ratings Matter

• - A good rating can catapult a boutique cigar into the spotlight.
• - Retailers often see increased demand after a top 25 ranking.
• - Ratings help guide both seasoned aficionados and beginners.

What Is a Blind Tasting, Really?

• - Reviewers don’t know the brand, country of origin, or price.
• - Bands are removed and replaced with a simple code.
• - Tastings are conducted over several months, with repeated smokes.

The Scoring Criteria

Publications like Cigar Aficionado, Cigar Journal, and others typically use a 100-point scale. Here's how that usually breaks down:

Annual ranking process is more than just smoke and mirrors. It centers around blind tastings, where cigar bands are stripped, replaced with neutral codes, and evaluated by a panel of expert tasters—typically seasoned editors with decades of combined experience—in multiple rounds to ensure fairness and consistency.

Scores are based on:

• - Appearance & Construction Quality
• - Aroma, Draw & Burn
• - Flavor Complexity
• - Balance & Strength
• - Overall Impression

How a “Cigar of the Year” Is Chosen

• - Only cigars released in the past year are eligible.
• - Must have received a high score (typically 91+) in regular reviews.
• - Editors re-smoke top-rated cigars and compare them side by side.
• - Factors like consistency, availability, and craftsmanship also matter.

The Critics: Who Are the Tasters?

• - Most are veteran smokers with deep knowledge of blending and regions.
• - Publications sometimes invite guest panelists, but rarely disclose names.
• - Staff tasters undergo calibration sessions to align scoring.

How to Use Ratings as a Smoker

• - Use ratings as a starting point—not gospel.
• - Track which reviewers’ tastes match yours.
• - Try a mix of top-rated and under-the-radar cigars.

Final Puff: Ratings Are a Tool—Not a Rule

Cigar ratings are helpful guides, but the best cigar is always the one you enjoy most. Still, understanding the process behind those scores can deepen your appreciation—and maybe lead you to your next favorite smoke.

Thank you for visiting our online cigar shop! At Cigar Place, we're committed to bringing you the best prices, discounts, and deals on cigars, humidifiers, lighters, cutters, gifts, and a wide range of cigar accessories. Discover our extensive collection, featuring one of the largest selections of premium cigar brands and samplers.

As one of the most trusted online cigar retailers, with Cigar Place, you can always count on 100% freshness and quality for every cigar and product you purchase. Enjoy free shipping on all U.S. cigar orders when you purchase any cigar 5-pack, bundle, or sampler!